One year on, this is our pick!

We have has this pail for about a year and it is pretty good. We also have a diaper genie which we both hate. The diaper genie may contain the smell when it is closed, but when you open it, it smells MUCH worse. Plus the hassle of the "twistaway" system, special refills, claw thing you have to push the diapers thru and the tiny button to open and lift the lid are all BIG MINUSES FOR THE DIAPER GENIE.

The Easy Saver pail is very convenient, does not smell that bad (I mean what do you expect with week old poopy diapers in it?) and I love the pop up top on the lid. That is why it is better than a trash can...I disagree with people who say you should "save your money" and get a plain trash can. I mean COME ON THE THING IS ONLY 15 bucks! I think it holds in the smell fairly well and, as mentioned earlier, the pushbutton top is terribly convenient. We like using regular trashbags too.

I just wish there was a replacement deodorizer(I know ours is not working anymore), I may try some of the suggestions for stick-ups or plug-in refills that other people have mentioned in their reviews.